Comprehensive software reviews to make better IT decisions
Is Hyperconverged Infrastructure Storage or a Server? Yes!
Is a hyperconverged infrastructure (HCI) node or appliance a server or enterprise storage? It is both really, so what does it matter? Well, whether you think of HCI as a storage or a server will likely influence the products you eventually purchase.
In 2014 analysts at Wikibon launched a crowd discussion project to define a new architecture that would disrupt traditional storage. They named it “Server SAN.” The name didn’t really catch on. It wasn’t as cool as hyperconvergence, I guess.
Server SAN did sort of make sense. The architecture combined a virtual machine hosting server with a software defined storage array that was functionally like a storage area network (SAN) array. Server plus SAN array equals Server SAN.
But the Server SAN also represented the next step of the ongoing trend of convergence and abstraction (virtualization, software defined) in infrastructure. So if a server shelf, a switch, and a SAN array sold together in a single SKU was “converged infrastructure,” what do you call it when the functionality of all three is combine in one appliance?
Well, that there is hyperconverged infrastructure, my friend.
At the end of the day, though, is this the case of software defined storage consuming the server hosting function or is it just servers taking back the storage function after years of externalized storage ascendancy? Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, allow me to present the case for each position.
HCI Is SAN Storage
Nearly all leading HCI products – whether Nutanix or HP Simplivity or Scale Computing or Pivot3 or half a dozen others – began as external storage products. They began as methods of clustering commodity storage servers together and pool it all as a virtual SAN array. The hosting of server VMs came later.
HCI was initially pitched at niche cases such as hosting virtual desktop infrastructure (VDI). But more recently HCI vendors have been targeting companies looking to replace end of life general purpose SAN storage. Nutanix has been particularly good at this. Looking to replace an aging midrange NetApp or EMC array? Chances are that you’re going to get a call from a Nutanix seller.
From the industry analyst point of view, analyst queries about HCI typically came from midrange organizations, such as larger professional services firms that were looking to purchase storage and had been preached the hyperconvergence gospel according to Nutanix (or Symplivity).
Incidentally, servicing IT departments considering HCI as a storage purchase is why VMware vSAN is not ranked in our Hyperconverged Infrastructure Vendor Landscape. The HCI VL is very much a continuation of our SAN array VLs (It was published concurrently with a new VL on Midrange Storage Arrays).
In the past we have focused on branded storage hardware in the Vendor Landscapes on the basis of this being a hardware acquisition. Software only solutions have been ruled out of scope. In the age of software defined everything you can argue with that but that has been our rule. VMware vSAN has been included in a number of analyst firms’ Vendor Landscape equivalents, but for ours it was not ranked but included as “alternative considerations” along with other software plays like Maxta and Scale Computing.
Alternative Considerations: 2017 HCI Vendor Landscape
HCI Is Server Software
First allow me to let you in on a little secret. All storage arrays are servers. A server is a networked computing device that typically has a central processing unit (CPU), memory, and hard storage (spinning rust or more recently solid state). A storage array is a server – or server cluster – with a large amount of storage traditionally in the form of large numbers of hard disk drives. Increasingly the CPU has been Intel x86, just like any other server.
Here’s another kicker. External storage has always been software defined. It is software that tells a server what it is. In external storage the system software tells the CPU that it is something called a storage controller. Traditionally this software has been hard coded into controller chips but more recently been purely software in memory. This is where the idea of “software defined” comes from. The storage controller software is in memory, not on hardware.
In a VMware vSAN ready mode, for example, the VMware software is telling the server that it is both a virtual machine host and a software defined storage array. Nutanix software does the same thing but uses its storage management software for the storage cluster.
Going back to our Vendor Landscape case, VMware has been included in many HCI quadrants and waves because there is an awful lot of vSAN out there running on servers from a variety of vendors. Dell, incidentally, is a market leader because they have HCI products running both vSAN and the Nutanix stack.
What can you do with this information? For your infrastructure, what really matters is how you view storage. Are you a storage power user that requires enterprise class block storage with all the bells and whistles? Or are you a traditional distributed server jock that always resented having to buy a SAN array to make server virtualization and consolidation work?
- Start with your real storage requirements.
Chances are that you are looking at hyperconvergence because your legacy SAN array is reaching end of life. Work through your storage RFP requirements. If you have true enterprise requirements you’ll likely look at higher-end HCI such as Nutanix or HPE Simplivity. More standard requirements may well be met by servers running HCI software (such as vSAN).
- Think server nodes for private cloud.
Cloud computing services from Amazon to Facebook are built on commodity server hardware running proprietary HCI software. If you want to be more like them, focus on commodity hardware running hardware agnostic HCI software – vSAN but also open-source based options like Scale Computing.
- Prepare for the end of storage.
OK, that’s dramatic. But a separate external general purpose array for general purpose servers is being disrupted. Midrange storage arrays only became necessary because of the limitations of direct attached storage within servers. With software defined storage and hyperconvergence software, the storage is coming home to the servers. There will be less need for separate hardware and separate management roles in IT.
Is HCI next generation enterprise storage or just a glorified server? It is both: advanced software defined storage incorporated into server hardware. But how you think about HCI, as a storage and server investment, will have an impact on the classes of HCI products you will likely need.
Want to Know More?
On January 23, Microsoft announced a change to Office 365 Pro Plus. This change will make Bing the default search engine in Google Chrome.
Veeam to be acquired by Insight Partners for US$5 billion: On January 9, 2020, Veeam announced that it has entered into a definitive agreement of purchase with Insight Partners.
Zerto 7.5 adds support for Azure Active Directory Managed Service Identity (MSI), which simplifies authentication to Azure services while improving security.
Quest Software’s NetVault Backup v12.4 release adds support for OneDrive to its existing Office 365 (O365) backup capabilities, enabling its customers to better align backup strategy to business requirements, and helping Quest Software keep up with other O365 backup offerings.
Veeam has rolled out new backup features that integrate with Amazon S3 to help users save on storage costs for their backups. This tech is some serious secret sauce.
HPE has ported over InfoSight Predictive Analytics platform from its 2017 acquisition of Nimble to its SimpliVity line, adding AI to the hyperconverged infrastructure (HCI), as announced in an Oct. 28 press release.
Fluid Framework, unveiled in May at Microsoft’s Build 2019 company conference, lets developers rally the help of near real-time coauthoring, reusable mix-and-match document components, and digital assistants like translator aids in the content creation experience at speeds and scale not available before.
Veeam is still running strong in the enterprise and cloud backup markets two business quarters into its 2019 fiscal year. Veeam has announced its second quarter results and the numbers are still impressive.
K2 Software, a major player in the business process management (BPM) space, has partnered with Dropbox, a trailblazer in cloud storage and collaboration solutions. The partnership aims to streamline how business groups using different systems manage information together.