Optimize IT Project Intake, Approval, and Prioritization
Decide which IT projects to approve and when to start them.
Companies are approving more projects than they can deliver. Most organizations say they have too many projects on the go and an unmanageable and ever-growing backlog of things to get to.
While organizations want to achieve a high throughput of approved projects, many are unable or unwilling to allocate an appropriate level of IT resourcing to adequately match the number of approved initiatives.
Portfolio management practices must find a way to accommodate stakeholder needs without sacrificing the portfolio to low-value initiatives that do not align with business goals.
Our Advice
Critical Insight
Approve only the right projects that you have capacity to deliver. Failure to align projects with strategic goals and resource capacity are the most common causes of portfolio waste across organizations.
More time spent with stakeholders during the ideation phase to help set realistic expectations for stakeholders and enhance visibility into IT’s capacity and processes is key to both project and organizational success.
Too much intake red tape will lead to an underground economy of projects that escape portfolio oversight, while too little intake formality will lead to a wild west of approvals that could overwhelm the PMO. Finding the right balance of intake formality for your organization is the key to establishing a PMO that has the ability to focus on the right things.
Impact and Result
Establish an effective scorecard to create transparency into IT’s capacity and processes. This will help set realistic expectations for stakeholders, eliminate “squeaky wheel” prioritization, and give primacy to the highest value requests.
Build a centralized process that funnels requests into a single intake channel to eliminate confusion and doubt for stakeholders and staff while also reducing off-the-grid initiatives.
Clearly define a series of project approval steps, and communicate requirements for passing them.
Develop practices that incorporate the constraint of resource capacity to cap the amount of project approvals to that which is realistic to help improve the throughput of projects through the portfolio.
Research & Tools
Start here – read the Executive Brief
Read our concise
Executive Brief to find out why you should optimize project intake, approval,
and prioritization process, review Info-Tech’s methodology, and understand the
four ways we can support you in completing this project.
1. Set realistic goals for optimizing project intake, approval, and prioritization process
Get value early by piloting
a scorecard for objectively determining project value, and then examine your
current state of project intake to set realistic goals for optimizing the process.
2. Build an optimized project intake, approval, and prioritization process
Take a deeper dive
into each of the three processes – intake, approval, and prioritization – to
ensure that the portfolio of projects is best aligned to stakeholder needs,
strategic objectives, and resource capacity.
3. Integrate the new optimized processes into practice
Plan a course of
action to pilot, refine, and communicate the new optimized process using
Info-Tech’s expertise in organizational change management.
Member Testimonials
After each Info-Tech experience, we ask our members to quantify the real-time savings, monetary impact, and project improvements our research helped them achieve. See our top member experiences for this blueprint and what our clients have to say.
9.5/10
Overall Impact
$46,271
Average $ Saved
29
Average Days Saved
Member Testimonials
Client
Vanderbilt University Medical Center
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
N/A
Testimonial
Long Dam consistently makes each session engaging and valuable. His responses are thoughtful, intentional, and professional, and his guidance refle...
Long Dam consistently makes each session engaging and valuable. His responses are thoughtful, intentional, and professional, and his guidance reflects a clear understanding of our needs. He has become a trusted resource, and I greatly appreciate the insight and practical guidance he brings to every conversation.
Member Testimonials
Client
Affinity Plus Federal Credit Union
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
N/A
Testimonial
Elvis was able to relate these tools to real-life scenarios, help me anticipate questions or push-back I might received within my organization when...
Elvis was able to relate these tools to real-life scenarios, help me anticipate questions or push-back I might received within my organization when it comes to implementing these practices, he also built my confidence & confirmed I've been on the right track, but due to our engagement I think I've matured our practices with Elvis in 2 months which would have likely taken 12 months without his guidance.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
9/10
$ Saved
$4,000
Days Saved
10
Testimonial
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
N/A
Testimonial
This has been a valuable learning experience in working to optimize our IT intake and prioritization process. The best parts is Elvis keeping it si...
This has been a valuable learning experience in working to optimize our IT intake and prioritization process. The best parts is Elvis keeping it simple and providing practical and insightful ways for me to envision how to adopt it to our organization and workings. The worst part is having to do homework with everything else going on at work, but then, how could I get it to work for our organization without these homework :)
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
20
Testimonial
Best: Advice given during the meetings was very constructive and insightful. The step by step instructions received assisted tremendously in build...
Best: Advice given during the meetings was very constructive and insightful. The step by step instructions received assisted tremendously in building out our IT Project Intake Process.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$24,500
Days Saved
20
Testimonial
Elvis is clearly very knowlegeable about PPM as a topic. He did a fantastic job of covering the material, and providing insights. With his help I w...
Elvis is clearly very knowlegeable about PPM as a topic. He did a fantastic job of covering the material, and providing insights. With his help I was able to complete the module across 6-7 sessions, and I've walked away with a deeper understanding of PPM, and a suite of tools that will help our business on the journey to standing up a dedicated PPM function. Thanks Elvis!
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$8,279
Days Saved
5
Testimonial
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$2,483
Days Saved
2
Testimonial
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
9/10
$ Saved
$2,069
Days Saved
5
Testimonial
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Workshop
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
120
Testimonial
The items presented above do not allow me the opportunity to adequately express the value I believe we stand to realize from our workshop with Bill...
The items presented above do not allow me the opportunity to adequately express the value I believe we stand to realize from our workshop with Bill. Certainly, the value we will benefit from the workshop is hands down a 10. As for the amount of time we will save, the sky is the limit. Bill has prepared us to implement strategies that could potentially save us far more days than the scale above allows for. As for the financial impact, again the sky is the limit. A complete lack of any meaningful project intake is our current landscape. Thus, the dire need for this workshop. As you can imagine, much time, effort and money are routinely wasted in such an environment. The knowledge and toolset Bill has imparted to us will be invaluable; about that there is no doubt. At this point, Bill has joined us for five years to lead our workshops. This was not by chance, but instead by choice. We are always excited to learn that he has accepted our invitation, yet again. He has been with us long enough to truly understand and appreciate the challenges we face, and he comes each visit with the intention of helping us overcome these challenges. The real value comes from his extensive experience. He's a thinker, and he forces us to think in a way that is contrary to what we've done historically. Make no mistake, there's an art to that. Not just everyone has that skill. We appreciate Bill more than he knows and look forward to inviting him back to assist us in meeting additional challenges we face, if he will be so gracious to accept. Thank you!
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$68,999
Days Saved
10
Testimonial
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$25,000
Days Saved
20
Testimonial
Great experience with Long. He walked me through the method and possible tools to use, as well as ways to fit the tools to our specific needs.
No b...
Great experience with Long. He walked me through the method and possible tools to use, as well as ways to fit the tools to our specific needs.
No bad experiences.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$13,799
Days Saved
20
Testimonial
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$2,759
Days Saved
5
Testimonial
The timing of this workshop was perfect. It really helped provide some options around a situation I am running up against and will help guide some ...
The timing of this workshop was perfect. It really helped provide some options around a situation I am running up against and will help guide some actionable items in the near future. I find these very valuable - my biggest issue is taking what I learn and moving on it, in a measured way to ensure adoption and acceptance. That just takes a lot longer to execute than learn, but thankful for the resources.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$15,869
Days Saved
10
Testimonial
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$137K
Days Saved
120
Testimonial
No worst parts and only best. The tools are exactly what we've been looking for. They cover all requirements, easily understandable, and ready to g...
No worst parts and only best. The tools are exactly what we've been looking for. They cover all requirements, easily understandable, and ready to go into production.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
35
Testimonial
This engagement helped us jumpstart our PMO refresh process and develop a project intake process, which we sorely needed. No true worst part, but ...
This engagement helped us jumpstart our PMO refresh process and develop a project intake process, which we sorely needed. No true worst part, but due to the unique nature of our work, some of the templates were not a good fit for our organization, however Elvis was really helpful providing suggestions on how we can modify some of the resources to fit our needs.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$2,759
Days Saved
1
Testimonial
Thank you for all of your help working through the prioritization tool Matt :-)
Thank you for all of your help working through the prioritization tool Matt :-)
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
10
Testimonial
It was great to have a subjective and external advisor, who has both experience and practical, ready-to-use tool sets, to point out process opportu...
It was great to have a subjective and external advisor, who has both experience and practical, ready-to-use tool sets, to point out process opportunities and blind spots. It not only reinforces our collective understanding but also built my confidence in my own professional instincts/judgement. Having a clear and focused guidance also breaks any echo chambers - a real hindrance in progressing with different ideas.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
9/10
$ Saved
$55,000
Days Saved
32
Testimonial
Knowledge, expertise and past experiences with other customers.
Knowledge, expertise and past experiences with other customers.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
9/10
$ Saved
$13,799
Days Saved
10
Testimonial
Elvis was a great facilitator who brought a lot of energy to the material and supplemented it appropriately with other InfoTech resources and his p...
Elvis was a great facilitator who brought a lot of energy to the material and supplemented it appropriately with other InfoTech resources and his personal experience.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
2
Testimonial
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
N/A
Testimonial
Elvis provides me with a lot of guidance and we are working well together. I really appreciate his support and I'm looking forward to continuing ou...
Elvis provides me with a lot of guidance and we are working well together. I really appreciate his support and I'm looking forward to continuing our collaboration
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$51,749
Days Saved
47
Testimonial
Over the past several months, Michael and I have had the privilege of working closely with Elvis from InfoTech on project prioritization, scoring, ...
Over the past several months, Michael and I have had the privilege of working closely with Elvis from InfoTech on project prioritization, scoring, and the intake process. Elvis has been an exceptional partner throughout this engagement.
From the start, he demonstrated deep expertise in these areas—particularly within higher education—which allowed him to guide us effectively through our challenges. His ability to listen, understand our pain points, and provide thoughtful, tailored recommendations has been invaluable. Whenever I raised questions or concerns about customizing the process for VCCS, Elvis offered clear, well-reasoned explanations and practical solutions.
One of the most impactful aspects of his support has been the time savings he enabled. By providing pre-populated presentations and spreadsheets and then guiding us through customization, Elvis accelerated our progress significantly. His approach ensured that we not only improved our process but also positioned ourselves to communicate these changes effectively to leadership and gain buy-in.
This work has been especially critical given the leadership transitions we’ve experienced, including several CIO changes and other high-level shifts. Thanks to Elvis’s guidance, we are now well-prepared to implement needed changes and sustain improvements moving forward.
I cannot overstate how helpful Elvis has been to our organization. His professionalism, expertise, and collaborative approach have made a lasting impact.
The best parts of the experience have been the dialog we've been able to have with Elvis as we struggled with our current process as well as the tools that he has been able to provide us with that will be so useful moving forward. There are no worse parts other than our own internal struggles being pulled in many different directions due to leadership changes.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
8/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
N/A
Testimonial
Can't specifically answer the question on budget / time saved but walking through this with Long was great - he is extremely knowledgeable and show...
Can't specifically answer the question on budget / time saved but walking through this with Long was great - he is extremely knowledgeable and showed me how I can do things like resourcing etc.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
9/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
N/A
Testimonial
Good examples provided, useful tools and consideration of key criteria. Good advice on filtering initial requests.
Good examples provided, useful tools and consideration of key criteria. Good advice on filtering initial requests.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$34,499
Days Saved
5
Testimonial
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$25,000
Days Saved
10
Testimonial
We now have a tool that is extremely useful for us. Matt has been fantastic
We now have a tool that is extremely useful for us. Matt has been fantastic
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
N/A
Days Saved
100
Testimonial
We absolutely love Elvis! He is on point and extremely organized. He knows his subject matter inside and out and is an extremely valuable resourc...
We absolutely love Elvis! He is on point and extremely organized. He knows his subject matter inside and out and is an extremely valuable resource for us. Without Elvis we would not have the clarity to move forward with our IT PMO. Just for context, there have been two other attempts to lift this off the ground by separate teams in the past 20 years that were unsuccessful.
We have been so lucky to be paired with Elvis.
Here at PRP, I can't really put a number to how much savings - financially the impact of Infotech has provided.
Member Testimonials
Client
Member Organization
Experience
Guided Implementation
Impact
10/10
$ Saved
$20,500
Days Saved
20
Testimonial
Working with Elvis was an absolute pleasure. Personable and genuinely wonderful to collaborate with, he created an environment that was both welcom...
Working with Elvis was an absolute pleasure. Personable and genuinely wonderful to collaborate with, he created an environment that was both welcoming and highly productive. I really appreciated how he consistently brought real-life scenarios into our conversations, which made complex concepts easier to grasp and directly relevant to our work. What really stood out was his ability to break the program into manageable portions that was easy to understand and then piece them together into a comprehensive portfolio tailored for our Board. The approach not only built clarity but also confidence in the process, and I am truly grateful for the expertise and support he brought to achieving project optimization for York Catholic. In terms of a "worst part", that is hard to pinpoint. The only real challenge we faced was timing, as this initiative began right on the cusp of summer when I was preparing to take significant time off. This naturally created some pressure to move quickly. However, Elvis was incredibly accommodating and supportive throughout, which made all the difference and ensured we stayed on track despite the circumstances.
Member Testimonials
Client
Experience
Impact
$ Saved
Days Saved
Testimonial
Vanderbilt University Medical Center
Guided Implementation
10/10
N/A
N/A
Long Dam consistently makes each session engaging and valuable. His responses are thoughtful, intentional, and professional, and his guidance refle...
Long Dam consistently makes each session engaging and valuable. His responses are thoughtful, intentional, and professional, and his guidance reflects a clear understanding of our needs. He has become a trusted resource, and I greatly appreciate the insight and practical guidance he brings to every conversation.
Affinity Plus Federal Credit Union
Guided Implementation
10/10
N/A
N/A
Elvis was able to relate these tools to real-life scenarios, help me anticipate questions or push-back I might received within my organization when...
Elvis was able to relate these tools to real-life scenarios, help me anticipate questions or push-back I might received within my organization when it comes to implementing these practices, he also built my confidence & confirmed I've been on the right track, but due to our engagement I think I've matured our practices with Elvis in 2 months which would have likely taken 12 months without his guidance.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
9/10
$4,000
10
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
N/A
N/A
This has been a valuable learning experience in working to optimize our IT intake and prioritization process. The best parts is Elvis keeping it si...
This has been a valuable learning experience in working to optimize our IT intake and prioritization process. The best parts is Elvis keeping it simple and providing practical and insightful ways for me to envision how to adopt it to our organization and workings. The worst part is having to do homework with everything else going on at work, but then, how could I get it to work for our organization without these homework :)
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
N/A
20
Best: Advice given during the meetings was very constructive and insightful. The step by step instructions received assisted tremendously in build...
Best: Advice given during the meetings was very constructive and insightful. The step by step instructions received assisted tremendously in building out our IT Project Intake Process.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$24,500
20
Elvis is clearly very knowlegeable about PPM as a topic. He did a fantastic job of covering the material, and providing insights. With his help I w...
Elvis is clearly very knowlegeable about PPM as a topic. He did a fantastic job of covering the material, and providing insights. With his help I was able to complete the module across 6-7 sessions, and I've walked away with a deeper understanding of PPM, and a suite of tools that will help our business on the journey to standing up a dedicated PPM function. Thanks Elvis!
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$8,279
5
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$2,483
2
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
9/10
$2,069
5
Member Organization
Workshop
10/10
N/A
120
The items presented above do not allow me the opportunity to adequately express the value I believe we stand to realize from our workshop with Bill...
The items presented above do not allow me the opportunity to adequately express the value I believe we stand to realize from our workshop with Bill. Certainly, the value we will benefit from the workshop is hands down a 10. As for the amount of time we will save, the sky is the limit. Bill has prepared us to implement strategies that could potentially save us far more days than the scale above allows for. As for the financial impact, again the sky is the limit. A complete lack of any meaningful project intake is our current landscape. Thus, the dire need for this workshop. As you can imagine, much time, effort and money are routinely wasted in such an environment. The knowledge and toolset Bill has imparted to us will be invaluable; about that there is no doubt. At this point, Bill has joined us for five years to lead our workshops. This was not by chance, but instead by choice. We are always excited to learn that he has accepted our invitation, yet again. He has been with us long enough to truly understand and appreciate the challenges we face, and he comes each visit with the intention of helping us overcome these challenges. The real value comes from his extensive experience. He's a thinker, and he forces us to think in a way that is contrary to what we've done historically. Make no mistake, there's an art to that. Not just everyone has that skill. We appreciate Bill more than he knows and look forward to inviting him back to assist us in meeting additional challenges we face, if he will be so gracious to accept. Thank you!
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$68,999
10
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$25,000
20
Great experience with Long. He walked me through the method and possible tools to use, as well as ways to fit the tools to our specific needs.
No b...
Great experience with Long. He walked me through the method and possible tools to use, as well as ways to fit the tools to our specific needs.
No bad experiences.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$13,799
20
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$2,759
5
The timing of this workshop was perfect. It really helped provide some options around a situation I am running up against and will help guide some ...
The timing of this workshop was perfect. It really helped provide some options around a situation I am running up against and will help guide some actionable items in the near future. I find these very valuable - my biggest issue is taking what I learn and moving on it, in a measured way to ensure adoption and acceptance. That just takes a lot longer to execute than learn, but thankful for the resources.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$15,869
10
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$137K
120
No worst parts and only best. The tools are exactly what we've been looking for. They cover all requirements, easily understandable, and ready to g...
No worst parts and only best. The tools are exactly what we've been looking for. They cover all requirements, easily understandable, and ready to go into production.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
N/A
35
This engagement helped us jumpstart our PMO refresh process and develop a project intake process, which we sorely needed. No true worst part, but ...
This engagement helped us jumpstart our PMO refresh process and develop a project intake process, which we sorely needed. No true worst part, but due to the unique nature of our work, some of the templates were not a good fit for our organization, however Elvis was really helpful providing suggestions on how we can modify some of the resources to fit our needs.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$2,759
1
Thank you for all of your help working through the prioritization tool Matt :-)
Thank you for all of your help working through the prioritization tool Matt :-)
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
N/A
10
It was great to have a subjective and external advisor, who has both experience and practical, ready-to-use tool sets, to point out process opportu...
It was great to have a subjective and external advisor, who has both experience and practical, ready-to-use tool sets, to point out process opportunities and blind spots. It not only reinforces our collective understanding but also built my confidence in my own professional instincts/judgement. Having a clear and focused guidance also breaks any echo chambers - a real hindrance in progressing with different ideas.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
9/10
$55,000
32
Knowledge, expertise and past experiences with other customers.
Knowledge, expertise and past experiences with other customers.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
9/10
$13,799
10
Elvis was a great facilitator who brought a lot of energy to the material and supplemented it appropriately with other InfoTech resources and his p...
Elvis was a great facilitator who brought a lot of energy to the material and supplemented it appropriately with other InfoTech resources and his personal experience.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
N/A
2
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
N/A
N/A
Elvis provides me with a lot of guidance and we are working well together. I really appreciate his support and I'm looking forward to continuing ou...
Elvis provides me with a lot of guidance and we are working well together. I really appreciate his support and I'm looking forward to continuing our collaboration
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$51,749
47
Over the past several months, Michael and I have had the privilege of working closely with Elvis from InfoTech on project prioritization, scoring, ...
Over the past several months, Michael and I have had the privilege of working closely with Elvis from InfoTech on project prioritization, scoring, and the intake process. Elvis has been an exceptional partner throughout this engagement.
From the start, he demonstrated deep expertise in these areas—particularly within higher education—which allowed him to guide us effectively through our challenges. His ability to listen, understand our pain points, and provide thoughtful, tailored recommendations has been invaluable. Whenever I raised questions or concerns about customizing the process for VCCS, Elvis offered clear, well-reasoned explanations and practical solutions.
One of the most impactful aspects of his support has been the time savings he enabled. By providing pre-populated presentations and spreadsheets and then guiding us through customization, Elvis accelerated our progress significantly. His approach ensured that we not only improved our process but also positioned ourselves to communicate these changes effectively to leadership and gain buy-in.
This work has been especially critical given the leadership transitions we’ve experienced, including several CIO changes and other high-level shifts. Thanks to Elvis’s guidance, we are now well-prepared to implement needed changes and sustain improvements moving forward.
I cannot overstate how helpful Elvis has been to our organization. His professionalism, expertise, and collaborative approach have made a lasting impact.
The best parts of the experience have been the dialog we've been able to have with Elvis as we struggled with our current process as well as the tools that he has been able to provide us with that will be so useful moving forward. There are no worse parts other than our own internal struggles being pulled in many different directions due to leadership changes.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
8/10
N/A
N/A
Can't specifically answer the question on budget / time saved but walking through this with Long was great - he is extremely knowledgeable and show...
Can't specifically answer the question on budget / time saved but walking through this with Long was great - he is extremely knowledgeable and showed me how I can do things like resourcing etc.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
9/10
N/A
N/A
Good examples provided, useful tools and consideration of key criteria. Good advice on filtering initial requests.
Good examples provided, useful tools and consideration of key criteria. Good advice on filtering initial requests.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$34,499
5
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$25,000
10
We now have a tool that is extremely useful for us. Matt has been fantastic
We now have a tool that is extremely useful for us. Matt has been fantastic
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
N/A
100
We absolutely love Elvis! He is on point and extremely organized. He knows his subject matter inside and out and is an extremely valuable resourc...
We absolutely love Elvis! He is on point and extremely organized. He knows his subject matter inside and out and is an extremely valuable resource for us. Without Elvis we would not have the clarity to move forward with our IT PMO. Just for context, there have been two other attempts to lift this off the ground by separate teams in the past 20 years that were unsuccessful.
We have been so lucky to be paired with Elvis.
Here at PRP, I can't really put a number to how much savings - financially the impact of Infotech has provided.
Member Organization
Guided Implementation
10/10
$20,500
20
Working with Elvis was an absolute pleasure. Personable and genuinely wonderful to collaborate with, he created an environment that was both welcom...
Working with Elvis was an absolute pleasure. Personable and genuinely wonderful to collaborate with, he created an environment that was both welcoming and highly productive. I really appreciated how he consistently brought real-life scenarios into our conversations, which made complex concepts easier to grasp and directly relevant to our work. What really stood out was his ability to break the program into manageable portions that was easy to understand and then piece them together into a comprehensive portfolio tailored for our Board. The approach not only built clarity but also confidence in the process, and I am truly grateful for the expertise and support he brought to achieving project optimization for York Catholic. In terms of a "worst part", that is hard to pinpoint. The only real challenge we faced was timing, as this initiative began right on the cusp of summer when I was preparing to take significant time off. This naturally created some pressure to move quickly. However, Elvis was incredibly accommodating and supportive throughout, which made all the difference and ensured we stayed on track despite the circumstances.
Workshop
Optimize IT Project Intake, Approval, and Prioritization Workshop
Work with our analysts to accelerate this project using Info-Tech's proven workshop approach.
Module 1: Assess the PPM Capability
The Purpose
Set the course of action for optimizing project intake, approval, and prioritization by examining the current state of the process, the team, the stakeholders, and the organization as a whole.
Key Benefits Achieved
The overarching goal of optimizing project intake, approval, and prioritization process is to maximize the throughput of the best projects. To achieve this goal, one must have a clear way to determine what are “the best” projects.
Activities
Outputs
1.1
Complete the PPM current-state scorecard.
Outputs
PPM current-state scorecard
1.2
Evaluate your intake process current state.
Outputs
Project intake current state and maturity level
1.3
Determine your project intake maturity and discuss target state.
Drill down into, and optimize, each of the project intake, approval, and prioritization process.
Key Benefits Achieved
Info-Tech’s methodology systemically fits the project portfolio into its triple constraint of stakeholder needs, strategic objectives, and resource capacity, to effectively address the challenges of establishing organizational discipline for project intake.
Activities
Outputs
2.1
Define “project.”
Outputs
Project definition
2.2
Define project levels.
Outputs
Project levels matrix
2.3
Define project request process and create tool and template.
Outputs
Request process and associated templates and tools
2.4
Define project approval process and create tool and template.
Outputs
Approval process and associated templates and tools
Drill down into, and optimize, each of the project intake, approval, and prioritization process.
Key Benefits Achieved
Info-Tech’s methodology systemically fits the project portfolio into its triple constraint of stakeholder needs, strategic objectives, and resource capacity, to effectively address the challenges of establishing organizational discipline for project intake.
Activities
Outputs
3.1
Estimate resource capacity.
Outputs
3.2
Define project capacity and project t-shirt sizes.
Outputs
3.3
Test the Info-Tech Intake and Prioritization Tool.
Outputs
3.4
Optimize overall intake, approval and prioritization workflow.
Outputs
Target-state intake, approval, and prioritization process and workflow
Module 4: Implement & Maintain the Process
The Purpose
Analyze the stakeholder impact and responses to impending organizational change.
Create message canvases for at-risk change impacts and stakeholders.
Set the course of action for communicating changes to your stakeholders.
Key Benefits Achieved
A thorough organizational change impact analysis, based on Info-Tech’s expertise in organizational change management
Activities
Outputs
4.1
Review target-state intake, approval, and prioritization process and workflow.
Outputs
4.2
Complete stakeholder impact analysis.
Outputs
Stakeholder impact analysis
4.3
Develop communication approaches.
Outputs
Communication plan
4.4
Define implementation action items.
Outputs
Optimize IT Project Intake, Approval, and Prioritization
Decide which IT projects to approve and when to start them.
ANALYST PERSPECTIVE
Capacity-constrained intake is the only sustainable path forward.
"For years, the goal of project intake was to select the best projects. It makes sense and most people take it on faith without argument.
But if you end up with too many projects, it’s a bad strategy.
Don’t be afraid to say NO or NOT YET if you don’t have the capacity to deliver. People might give you a hard time in the near term, but you’re not helping by saying YES to things you can’t deliver."
Barry Cousins,
Senior Director, PMO Practice
Info-Tech Research Group
Our understanding of the problem
This Research Is Designed For:
PMO Directors who have trouble with project throughput
CIOs who want to improve IT’s responsive-ness to changing needs of the business
CIOs who want to maximize the overall business value of IT’s project portfolio
This Research Will Help You:
Align project intake and prioritization with resource capacity and strategic objectives
Balance proactive and reactive demand
Reduce portfolio waste on low-value projects
Manage project delivery expectations and satisfaction of business stakeholders
Get optimized project intake processes off the ground with low-cost, high-impact tools and templates
This Research Will Also Assist:
C-suite executives and steering committee members who want to ensure IT’s successful delivery of projects with high business impact
Project sponsors and product owners who seek visibility and transparency toward proposed projects
This Research Will Help Them:
Ensure that high-impact projects are approved and delivered in a timely manner
Gain clarity and visibility in IT’s project approval process
Improve your understanding of IT’s capacity to set more realistic expectations on what gets done
Executive summary
Situation
As a portfolio manager, you do not have the authority to decline or defer new projects – but you also lack the capacity to realistically say yes to more project work.
Stakeholders have unrealistic expectations of what IT can deliver. Too many projects are approved, and it may be unclear why their project is delayed or in a state of suspended animation.
Complication
The cycle of competition is making it increasingly difficult to follow a longer-term strategy during project intake, making it unproductive to approve projects for any horizon longer than one to two years.
As project portfolios become more aligned to “transformative” projects, resourcing for smaller, department-level projects becomes increasingly opaque.
Resolution
Establish an effective scorecard to create transparency into IT’s capacity and processes. This will help set realistic expectations for stakeholders, eliminate “squeaky wheel” prioritization, and give primacy to the highest value requests.
Build a centralized process that funnels requests into a single intake channel to eliminate confusion and doubt for stakeholders and staff while also reducing off-the-grid initiatives.
Clearly define a series of project approval steps, and communicate requirements for passing them.
Developing practices that incorporate the constraint of resource capacity to cap the amount of project approvals to that which is realistic will help improve the throughput of projects through the portfolio.
Info-Tech Insight
Approve only the right projects… Counterbalance stakeholder needs with strategic objectives of the business and that of IT, in order to maintain the value of your project portfolio at a high level.
…that you have capacity to deliver. Resource capacity-informed project approval process enables you to avoid biting off more than you can chew and, over time, build a track record of fulfilling promises to deliver on projects.
Most organizations are good at approving projects, but bad at starting them – and even worse at finishing them
Establishing project intake discipline should be a top priority from a long-term strategy and near-term tactical perspective.
Most organizations approve more projects than they can finish. In fact, many approve more than they can even start, leading to an ever-growing backlog where project ideas – often good ones – are never heard from again.
The appetite to approve more runs directly counter to the shortage of resources that plagues most IT departments. This tension of wanting more from less suggests that IT departments need to be more disciplined in choosing what to take on.
Info-Tech’s data shows that most IT organizations struggle with their project backlog (Source: N=397 organizations, Info-Tech Research Group PPM Current State Scorecard, 2017).
“There is a minimal list of pending projects”
“Last year we delivered the number of projects we anticipated at the start of the year”
The concept of fiduciary duty demonstrates the need for better discipline in choosing what projects to take on
Unless someone is accountable for making the right investment of resource capacity for the right projects, project intake discipline cannot be established effectively.
What is fiduciary duty?
Officers and directors owe their corporation the duty of acting in the corporation’s best interests over their own. They may delegate the responsibility of implementing the actions, but accountability can't be delegated; that is, they have the authority to make choices and are ultimately answerable for them.
No question is more important to the organization’s bottom line. Projects directly impact the bottom line because they require investment of resource time and money for the purposes of realizing benefits. The scarcity of resources requires that choices be made by those who have the right authority.
Who approves your projects?
Historically, the answer would have been the executive layer of the organization. However, in the 1990s management largely abdicated its obligation to control resources and expenditures via “employee empowerment.”
Controls on approvals became less rigid, and accountability for choosing what to do (and not do) shifted onto the shoulders of the individual worker. This creates a current paradigm where no one is accountable for the malinvestment…
…of resources that comes from approving too many projects. Instead, it’s up to individual workers to sink or swim as they attempt to reconcile, day after day, seemingly infinite organizational demand with their finite supply of working hours.
Ad hoc project selection schemes do not work
Without active management, reconciling the imbalance between demand with available work hours is a struggle that results largely in one of these two scenarios:
“Squeaky wheel”:Projects with the most vocal stakeholders behind them are worked on first.
IT is seen to favor certain lines of business, leading to disenfranchisement of other stakeholders.
Everything becomes the highest priority, which reinforces IT’s image as a firefighter, rather than a business value contributor
High-value projects without vocal support never get resourced; opportunities are missed.
“First in, first out”:Projects are approved and executed in the order they are requested.
Urgent or important projects for the business languish in the project backlog; opportunities are missed.
Low-value projects dominate the project portfolio.
Stakeholders leave IT out of the loop and resort to “underground economy” for getting their needs addressed.
80% of organizations feel that their portfolios are dominated by low-value initiatives that do not deliver value to the business (Source: Cooper).
Approve the right projects that you have capacity to deliver by actively managing the intake of projects
Project intake, approval, and prioritization (collectively “project intake”) reconciles the appetite for new projects with available resource capacity and strategic goals.
Project intake is a key process of project portfolio management (PPM). The Project Management Institute (PMI) describes PPM as:
"Interrelated organizational processes by which an organization evaluates, selects, prioritizes, and allocates its limited internal resources to best accomplish organizational strategies consistent with its vision, mission, and values."
(PMI, Standard for Portfolio Management, 3rd ed.)
Triple Constraint Model of the Project Portfolio
Project Intake:
Stakeholder Need
Strategic Objectives
Resource Capacity
All three components are required for the Project Portfolio
Organizations practicing PPM recognize available resource capacity as a constraint and aim to select projects – and commit the said capacity – to projects that:
Best satisfy the stakeholder needs that constantly change with the market
Best align to the strategic objectives and contribute the most to business
Have sufficient resource capacity available to best ensure consistent project throughput
92% vs. 74%: 92% of high-performing organizations in PPM report that projects are well aligned to strategic initiatives vs. 74% of low performers (PMI, 2015).
82% vs. 55%: 82% of high-performing organizations in PPM report that resources are effectively reallocated across projects vs. 55% of low performers (PMI, 2015)
Info-Tech’s data demonstrates that optimizing project intake can also improve business leaders’ satisfaction of IT
CEOs today perceive IT to be poorly aligned to business’ strategic goals:
43% of CEOs believe that business goals are going unsupported by IT (Source: Info-Tech’s CEO-CIO Alignment Survey (N=124)).
60% of CEOs believe that improvement is required around IT’s understanding of business goals (Source: Info-Tech’s CEO-CIO Alignment Survey (N=124)).
Business leaders today are generally dissatisfied with IT:
30% of business stakeholders are supporters of their IT departments (Source: Info-Tech’s CIO Business Vision Survey (N=21,367)).
The key to improving business satisfaction with IT is to deliver on projects that help the business achieve its strategic goals:
Source: Info-Tech’s CIO Business Vision Survey (N=21,367)
Optimized project intake not only improves the project portfolio’s alignment to business goals, but provides the most effective way to improve relationships with IT’s key stakeholders.
However, establishing organizational discipline for project intake, approval, and prioritization is difficult
Capacity awareness
Many IT departments struggle to realistically estimate available project capacity in a credible way. Stakeholders question the validity of your endeavor to install capacity-constrained intake process, and mistake it for unwillingness to cooperate instead.
Many moving parts
Project intake, approval, and prioritization involve the coordination of various departments. Therefore, they require a great deal of buy-in and compliance from multiple stakeholders and senior executives.
Lack of authority
Many PMOs and IT departments simply lack the ability to decline or defer new projects.
Unclear definition of value
Defining the project value is difficult because there are so many different and conflicting ways that are all valid in their own right. However, without it, it's impossible to fairly compare among projects to select what's "best."
Establishing intake discipline requires a great degree of cooperation and conformity among stakeholders that can be cultivated through strong processes.
Info-Tech’s intake, approval, and prioritization methodology systemically fits the project portfolio to its triple constraint
Info-Tech’s Methodology
Info-Tech’s Methodology
Project Intake
Project Approval
Project Prioritization
Project requests are submitted, received, triaged, and scoped in preparation for approval and prioritization.
Business cases are developed, evaluated, and selected (or declined) for investment, based on estimated value and feasibility.
Work is scheduled to begin, based on relative value, urgency, and availability of resources.
Stakeholder Needs
Strategic Objectives
Resource Capacity
Project Portfolio Triple Constraint
Info-Tech’s methodology for optimizing project intake delivers extraordinary value, fast
In the first step of the blueprint, you will prototype a set of scorecard criteria for determining project value.
Our methodology is designed to tackle your hardest challenge first to deliver the highest-value part of the deliverable. Since the overarching goal of optimizing project intake, approval, and prioritization process is to maximize the throughput of the best projects, one must define how “the best projects” are determined.
In nearly all instances…a key challenge for the PPM team is reaching agreement over how projects should rank.
– Merkhofer
A Project Value Scorecard will help you:
Evolve the discussions on project and portfolio value beyond a theoretical concept
Enable apples-to-apples comparisons amongst many different kinds of projects
The Project Value Scorecard Development Tool is designed to help you develop the project valuation scheme iteratively. Download the pre-filled tool with content that represents a common case, and then, customize it with your data.
This blueprint provides a clear path to maximizing your chance of success in optimizing project intake
Info-Tech’s practical, tactical research is accompanied by a suite of tools and templates to accelerate your process optimization efforts.
Organizational change and stakeholder management are critical elements of optimizing project intake, approval, and prioritization processes because they require a great degree of cooperation and conformity among stakeholders, and the list of key stakeholders are long and far-reaching.
This blueprint will provide a clear path to not only optimize the processes themselves, but also for the optimization effort itself. This research is organized into three phases, each requiring a few weeks of work at your team’s own pace – or all in one week, through a workshop facilitated by Info-Tech analysts.
Set Realistic Goals for Optimizing Project Intake, Approval, and Prioritization
Tools and Templates:
Project Value Scorecard Development Tool (.xlsx)
PPM Assessment Report (Info-Tech Diagnostics)
Standard Operating Procedure Template (.docx)
Build Optimized Project Intake, Approval, and Prioritization Processes
Integrate the Newly Optimized Processes into Practice
Tools and Templates:
Process Pilot Plan Template (.docx)
Impact Assessment and Communication Planning Tool (.xlsx)
Info-Tech’s approach to PPM is informed by industry best practices and rooted in practical insider research
Info-Tech uses PMI and ISACA frameworks for areas of this research.
PMI’s Standard for Portfolio Management, 3rd ed. is the leading industry framework, proving project portfolio management best practices and process guidelines.
COBIT 5 is the leading framework for the governance and management of enterprise IT.
In addition to industry-leading frameworks, our best-practice approach is enhanced by the insights and guidance from our analysts, industry experts, and our clients.
33,000+
Our peer network of over 33,000 happy clients proves the effectiveness of our research.
1,000+
Our team conducts 1,000+ hours of primary and secondary research to ensure that our approach is enhanced by best practices.
Deliver measurable project intake success for your organization with this blueprint
Measure the value of your effort to track your success quantitatively and demonstrate the proposed benefits, as you aim to do so with other projects through improved PPM.
Optimized project intake, approval, and prioritization processes lead to a high PPM maturity, which will improve the successful delivery and throughput of your projects, resource utilization, business alignment, and stakeholder satisfaction ((Source: BCG/PMI).
Measure your success through the following metrics:
Reduced turnaround time between project requests and initial scoping
Number of project proposals with articulated benefits
Reduction in “off-the-grid” projects
Team satisfaction and workplace engagement
PPM stakeholder satisfaction score from business stakeholders: see Info-Tech’s PPM Customer Satisfaction Diagnostics
$44,700: In the past 12 months, Info-Tech clients have reported an average measured value of $44,700 from undertaking a guided implementation of this research.
Add your own organization-specific goals, success criteria, and metrics by following the steps in the blueprint.
Case Study: Financial Services PMO prepares annual planning process with Project Value Scorecard Development Tool
CASE STUDY
Industry: Financial Services
Source: Info-Tech Client
Challenge
PMO plays a diverse set of roles, including project management for enterprise projects (i.e. PMI’s “Directive” PMO), standards management for department-level projects (i.e. PMI’s “Supportive” PMO), process governance of strategic projects (i.e. PMI’s “Controlling” PMO), and facilitation / planning / reporting for the corporate business strategy efforts (i.e. Enterprise PMO).
To facilitate the annual planning process, the PMO needed to develop a more data-driven and objective project intake process that implicitly aligned with the corporate strategy.
Solution
Info-Tech’s Project Value Scorecard tool was incorporated into the strategic planning process.
Results
The scorecard provided a simple way to list the competing strategic initiatives, objectively score them, and re-sort the results on demand as the leadership chooses to switch between ranking by overall score, project value, ability to execute, strategic alignment, operational alignment, and feasibility.
The Project Value Scorecard provided early value with multiple options for prioritized rankings.
Info-Tech offers various levels of support to best suit your needs
DIY Toolkit
“Our team has already made this critical project a priority, and we have the time and capability, but some guidance along the way would be helpful.”
Guided Implementation
“Our team knows that we need to fix a process, but we need assistance to determine where to focus. Some check-ins along the way would help keep us on track.”
Workshop
“We need to hit the ground running and get this project kicked off immediately. Our team has the ability to take this over once we get a framework and strategy in place.”
Consulting
“Our team does not have the time or the knowledge to take this project on. We need assistance through the entirety of this project.”
Diagnostics and consistent frameworks used throughout all four options
Optimize Project Intake, Approval, and Prioritization – project overview
1. Set Realistic Goals for Optimizing Process
2. Build New Optimized Processes
3. Integrate the New Processes into Practice
Best-Practice Toolkit
1.1 Define the criteria with which to determine project value.
2.1 Streamline intake to manage stakeholder expectations.
2.2 Set up steps of project approval to maximize strategic alignment while right-sizing the required effort.
2.3 Prioritize projects to maximize the value of the project portfolio within the constraint of resource capacity.
3.1 Pilot your intake, approval, and prioritization process to refine it before rollout.
3.2 Analyze the impact of organizational change through the eyes of PPM stakeholders to gain their buy-in.
Guided Implementations
Introduce Project Value Scorecard Development Tool and pilot Info-Tech’s example scorecard on your own backlog.
Map current project intake, approval, and prioritization process and key stakeholders.
Set realistic goals for process optimization.
Improve the management of stakeholder expectations with an optimized intake process.
Improve the alignment of the project portfolio to strategic objectives with an optimized approval process.
Enable resource capacity-constrained greenlighting of projects with an optimized prioritization process.
Create a process pilot strategy with supportive stakeholders.
Conduct a change impact analysis for your PPM stakeholders to create an effective communication strategy.
Roll out the new process and measure success.
Onsite Workshop
Module 1:
Refocus on Project Value to Set Realistic Goals for Optimizing Project Intake, Approval, and Prioritization Process
Module 2:
Examine, Optimize, and Document the New Project Intake, Approval, and Prioritization Process
Module 3:
Pilot, Plan, and Communicate the New Process and Its Required Organizational Changes
Phase 1 Outcome:
Draft project valuation criteria
Examination of current process
Definition of process success criteria
Phase 2 Outcome:
Documentation of new project intake, approval, and prioritization process
Tools and templates to aid the process
Phase 3 Outcome:
Process pilot plan
Organizational change communication plan
Workshop overview
Contact your account representative or email Workshops@InfoTech.com for more information.
Workshop Day 1
Workshop Day 2
Workshop Day 3
Workshop Day 4
Workshop Day 5
Activities
Benefits of optimizing project intake and project value definition
1.1 Complete and review PPM Current State Scorecard Assessment
1.2 Define project value for the organization
1.3 Engage key PPM stakeholders to iterate on the scorecard prototype
Set realistic goals for process optimization
2.1 Map current intake, approval, and prioritization workflow
2.2 Enumerate and prioritize process stakeholders
2.3 Determine the current and target capability levels
2.4 Define the process success criteria and KPIs
Optimize project intake and approval processes
3.1 Conduct focused retrospectives for project intake and approval
3.2 Define project levels
3.3 Optimize project intake processes
3.4 Optimize project approval processes
3.5 Compose SOP for intake and approval
3.6 Document the new intake and approval workflow
Optimize project prioritization process plan for a process pilot
4.1 Conduct focused retrospective for project prioritization
4.2 Estimate available resource capacity
4.3 Pilot Project Intake and Prioritization Tool with your project backlog
4.4 Compose SOP for prioritization
4.5 Document the new prioritization workflow
4.6 Discuss process pilot
Analyze stakeholder impact and create communication strategy
5.1 Analyze stakeholder impact and responses to impending organization change
5.2 Create message canvas for at-risk change impacts and stakeholders
5.3 Set course of action for communicating change
Deliverables
PPM Current State Scorecard
Project Value Scorecard prototype
Current intake, approval, and prioritization workflow
Stakeholder register
Intake process success criteria
Project request form
Project level classification matrix
Proposed project deliverables toolkit
Customized intake and approval SOP
Flowchart for the new intake and approval workflow
Estimated resource capacity for projects
Customized Project Intake and Prioritization Tool
Customized prioritization SOP
Flowchart for the new prioritization workflow
Process pilot plan
Completed Intake and Prioritization Impact Analysis Tool
Communication strategy and plan
Phase 1
Set Realistic Goals for Optimizing Project Intake, Approval, and Prioritization Process
This content is exclusive to members.
Sign up to continue reading the full blueprint, or sign in if you already have an account.
Our systems detected an issue with your IP. If you think this is an error please submit your concerns via our contact form.