Comprehensive Software Reviews to make better IT decisions

Sr hero 001 Sr hero 002 Sr hero 003 Sr hero 004

SAP S4/HANA and HANA Licensing Series – Part I: The Forced “Upgrade”

Current SAP ECC customers have a decision to make, as SAP has announced the end of ECC support effective 2025, in effect mandating a move to its next-generation ERP solution, S4/HANA. This is in spite of sources reporting that the S4/HANA codebase is over 90% identical to the legacy ECC product!

Mandated upgrades by enterprise software vendors are nothing new. The extension of these often artificial deadlines are not new either. In this case, however, SAP is mandating not just the typical upgrade but a net new purchase of the S4/HANA solution. You see, SAP’s legal beagles have designated S4/HANA a “logical successor” to ECC vs. a “legal successor.”

What does this mean in plain English? It means that there is no upgrade path to S4/HANA in spite of the many years and often millions of dollars spent on SAP enterprise support. It means that migrating to S4/HANA requires a net new license purchase. It is critical for SAP customers to become informed of the new aspects dealing with licensing and costs for S4/HANA and HANA before entering negotiations with SAP.

And if that pill wasn’t hard enough to swallow, it is equally important to realize that the only database certified to run S4/HANA is, you guessed it, SAP’s HANA database. This is a deliberate maneuver on the part of SAP to dislodge Oracle (and other DB solutions) off of the SAP ERP technology stack. Essentially, displace the competition while gaining that business for yourself.

SAP tried to drive business at the database layer through their acquisition of Sybase some time ago. Do you know anybody running Sybase? I don’t either. SAP has steadily declined to invest more in that product in recent years. In short, SAP is both forcing a new software license purchase for those customers that want to move to S4/HANA and simultaneously limiting customer choice at the database layer.

Our Take

This is the first in a series of short notes that aim to provide a rapid-fire base of the nuances, license changes, and performance attributes of S4/HANA vs. ECC and will also touch on the HANA database product. The takeaway for now is that a move to S4/HANA should be viewed as a re-platforming event, not an upgrade. As such, organizations should plan to treat this option under the guise of a competitive ERP RFP.


Want to Know More?

Subscription Growth Leads ServiceNow to a Strong 2018 Year-End Close
ServiceNow Asset Management